15 Common Mistakes People Make in New Friendships

15 Common Mistakes People Make in New Friendships

Making friends as an adult isn’t exactly a walk in the park. Gone are the days when bonding over crayons or dinosaurs could spark a lifelong friendship. Now, it requires effort, vulnerability, and sometimes stepping way outside your comfort zone. If you’re struggling to forge meaningful connections, it might be worth rethinking how you approach new friendships. Here are 15 common mistakes that might be holding you back—and how to fix them.

1. Thinking That Being Social Media ‘Friends’ Is Enough

Sad,Girl,With,Friends,Gossiping,In,Background,,Behind,Her,Back

Liking someone’s Instagram post or commenting on a Facebook photo might feel like you’re staying connected, but it’s a poor substitute for real interaction. Social media often creates an illusion of closeness without any actual substance. Instead of relying on likes and DMs, prioritize face-to-face time, phone calls, or even video chats to nurture a deeper connection.

2. Staying in Your Comfort Zone

It’s easy to stick to your cozy routine—bingeing Netflix, spending weekends solo, or sticking with the same small circle of people. But staying in your comfort zone keeps new friendships at arm’s length. Making an effort to try new activities, join social events, or simply say yes to invitations can open the door to meaningful connections.

3. Treating Friendships Like Optional Extras

Life gets busy, and it’s tempting to put friendships on the back burner. But relationships need time and effort to thrive. If you’re not prioritizing them, they’ll fade into the background. Block out time in your calendar for coffee dates, check-ins, or shared activities. Consistency builds trust and deepens bonds.

4. Fearing That Having Friends Means You Can’t Be Independent

If you’ve been fiercely self-reliant, letting someone into your life might feel like giving up control. But true friendship doesn’t mean losing your independence—it enhances it. The right friends will respect your boundaries and add richness to your life without taking anything away. It’s about balance, not sacrifice.

5. Assuming People Aren’t Interested

Convincing yourself that people don’t need more friends or wouldn’t want to hang out with you is self-sabotage. Most people are open to new friendships—they’re just as nervous about reaching out as you are. Take the first step and show interest. You might be surprised by how many doors it opens.

6. Avoiding Small Talk

Small talk gets a bad rap, but it’s often the gateway to deeper conversations. Pushing through the initial awkwardness can lead to genuine connection. Those seemingly trivial exchanges about the weather or your favorite TV shows can set the stage for meaningful relationships over time.

7. Expecting Instant Connections

Not every friendship starts with fireworks. If you’re looking for immediate chemistry, you might overlook great potential friends. Relationships often take time to grow. Showing up consistently, sharing experiences, and building trust slowly are the keys to creating something lasting and meaningful.

8. Waiting for the Other Person to Make a Move

Friendship is a two-way street, but someone has to take the first step. If you’re always waiting for others to reach out, you might miss out on great connections because you let yourself be ruled by fear and the voices in your head. Don’t be afraid to initiate plans or strike up conversations—it shows confidence and interest, which are key to forming bonds.

9. Letting Rejection Scare You Off

Rejection stings, but it’s not the end of the world. Not everyone will vibe with you, and that’s okay. Instead of dwelling on the no’s, focus on finding people who appreciate you for who you are. Every rejection is one step closer to the right connection. When you finally do meet “your people” all those moments of rejection will simply fade away.

10. Keeping Walls Up

Building meaningful friendships requires vulnerability. If you’re constantly keeping people at arm’s length, they’ll struggle to connect with you. Letting your guard down can be scary, but it’s necessary for authentic relationships. Start small, and gradually open up as trust grows. It seems really scary at first, but there’s something beautiful about trusting someone and sharing things with another person.

11. Overthinking Every Interaction

If you find yourself replaying conversations and analyzing every word you said, you’re not alone—but it’s exhausting. Most people aren’t scrutinizing you as much as you think. Letting go of the need to be perfect will make it easier to relax and genuinely connect with others. When you stop overthinking everything, you become the best version of yourself.

12. Setting Unrealistic Expectations for Yourself

Friendships aren’t a performance. If you’re pressuring yourself to always be the most entertaining, interesting, or likable person, you’re missing the point. Authenticity is far more valuable than perfection. Show up as you are, and let the connection happen naturally. When you stop the charade, that’s when some of the best people will see you for you.

13. Being Too Quick to Write People Off

Healthy boundaries are important, but cutting people off at the first sign of imperfection might leave you lonely. Friendships require patience and flexibility. Moreover, you won’t always agree with your friends on everything, or like what they do for that matter, but you need to learn to stop being so judgmental. Instead of immediately assuming someone isn’t a good fit, give them time to show who they really are.

14. Letting Past Hurts Hold You Back

If you’ve been betrayed or hurt by a friend before, it’s understandable to be cautious. But carrying that pain into new relationships keeps you stuck. Healing takes time, but being open to new connections is worth the effort. Not everyone will let you down. Once you learn that lesson, beautiful friends will start flocking into your life.

15. Not Giving Friendships Time to Grow

Good friendships aren’t built overnight. Expecting instant closeness can lead to frustration and missed opportunities. Be patient and give relationships the time they need to develop. Consistency, shared experiences, and trust will turn casual acquaintances into lasting friends.

This content was created by a real person with the assistance of AI.

Georgia is a self-help enthusiast and writer dedicated to exploring how better relationships lead to a better life. With a passion for personal growth, she breaks down the best insights on communication, boundaries, and connection into practical, relatable advice. Her goal is to help readers build stronger, healthier relationships—starting with the one they have with themselves.