A few weeks ago, I mentioned at a dinner that a friend of mine had been laid off. The man across from me set his glass down, held my eyes a beat too long, and said, “The universe never closes a door without opening a window.” Then he nodded slowly, like he’d just laid down a profound, Yoda-like wisdom.
I nodded back. The whole table nodded. And on the walk home I tried to work out what he’d actually told me, and the sentence came apart in my hands. My friend was still unemployed. No window had been located.
There’s a particular kind of talker who wants to be seen as deep in the same way people who want to sound smarter than they are want to be seen as clever. The smart-sounding version corrects you. The deep-sounding version consoles you, or gazes past you, with a line that feels like wisdom and dissolves the second you ask what it means.
The tell isn’t that these phrases are wrong. It’s that they can’t be wrong, because they don’t say anything.
1. “Everything happens for a reason”
Someone’s dog dies. Someone’s engagement ends. Someone loses the job they moved across the country for. And before the grief has a name, this arrives, delivered in the soft voice people reserve for things they believe are profound.
Ask what the reason is and you get the second half of the script: You’ll see. The phrase promises an explanation and then declines to provide one. It names a reason the way a locked box names its contents.
What it does is end the conversation. The person hurting is now expected to be comforted, and if they aren’t, the problem has quietly become their lack of perspective.
Yale psychologist Paul Bloom, who studied this belief with researcher Konika Banerjee, found that even many atheists reach for it, and he doesn’t think much of it. “I think the idea that ‘everything happens for a reason’ is ultimately foolish,” he told ORBITER magazine, calling it a cognitive bias.
He also noted that Banerjee came across forums where cancer patients said they hated hearing it.
2. “It is what it is”
A project collapses. A relationship ends badly. A coworker gets blamed for something that wasn’t theirs. And someone at the table exhales, shrugs, and says it.
It’s a sentence whose subject and predicate are the same word. It sounds like acceptance, maybe even hard-won wisdom, but all it does is confirm that a thing is itself.
People say it when they don’t want to think about something anymore and would prefer you didn’t either. It plays as calm. It functions as a door closing.
Linguist Amanda Montell, author of Cultish, told The Mary Sue that this is a textbook thought-terminating cliché, a term psychiatrist Robert Jay Lifton coined in the 1960s for stock phrases that are easy to memorize, easy to repeat, and designed to halt independent thinking.
More Bolde Stories
3. “I’m an old soul”
This one is a self-description, which should be the first clue. People with old souls, whatever that means, are not usually the ones announcing it over cocktails.
In practice it translates to: I like older music, I get tired early, and I’d like you to think that’s a spiritual trait rather than a preference.
Nobody can check it. There’s no test. It can’t be disproven, which is exactly why it gets said. And it carries a small ranking inside it, placing the speaker a notch above everyone still wandering around with a new soul.
4. “The energy was off”
They left the party early. When you ask why, they don’t say the host was rude or the music was loud or they were bored. They say the energy was off, and they say it like a diagnosis.
It replaces an opinion with a reading. I didn’t like those people is an opinion you can push back on. The energy was off is a report from an instrument only they possess.
You can’t argue with it, because there’s nothing to argue with. That’s the point of saying it this way.
Dutch psychologists Roos Vonk and Anouk Visser built a scale for what they called spiritual superiority, the sense of being more enlightened than other people, and found it ran highest among students of energetic practices like aura reading and energy healing, and tracked with measures of narcissism.
5. “Not everyone is meant to understand your journey”
This gets offered after you’ve been criticized, usually fairly. A friend told you the truth about something, and now someone else is here to tell you that the friend simply lacks the capacity to see what you’re doing.
It takes a disagreement and reframes it as a limitation on the other person’s part. No argument is answered. The critic is just gently demoted.
And the journey is never specified. It doesn’t need to be. The phrase works for anyone, going anywhere, which is another way of saying it describes no one.
More Bolde Stories
6. “Trust the process”
You only hear this when the process isn’t working. Nobody says it on the day the plan pays off. They say it in month four of a plan that has produced nothing, in the tone of someone who has decided your doubt is the real obstacle.
Which process? Toward what? By when?
The phrase asks for faith and offers no mechanism, and it quietly moves the burden of proof onto the person asking reasonable questions.
It sounds like patience. It’s usually just a request to stop looking at the results.
7. “You’re exactly where you’re supposed to be”
Said to someone who is broke, or heartbroken, or stalled, and said with total confidence. The speaker has no idea where that person is supposed to be. Neither does the person. But the sentence lands warm, so it does its job.
Notice that it would be equally true if the listener had just gotten married, gotten fired, or gotten lost in a parking garage. A statement that fits every situation isn’t insight. It’s a horoscope.
Psychologists have a name for the way vague, flattering statements feel personally tailored.
Registered psychotherapist Natacha Duke, writing for Cleveland Clinic about the Barnum effect, put it simply: “Vague or broad statements can really seem personal.” The effect dates to a 1948 experiment in which Bertram Forer’s students rated an identical personality sketch, lifted from an astrology book, as uncannily accurate.
8. “Let go of what no longer serves you”
It has the shape of advice. There’s a verb. There’s an object. And yet after it’s said, nothing has been recommended, because the object was never named.
What no longer serves you? A relationship? A job? A habit? A belief? The sentence can mean quit your marriage or quit sugar, and the speaker has committed to neither.
Real advice can be wrong, and that’s what makes it advice. This can’t be wrong. It can only be nodded at.
More Bolde Stories
9. “Everything is connected”
This is the big one, usually delivered late at night with a hand gesture that takes in the whole room. It’s true in the way that “things exist” is true, and it’s useful in no way at all.
Connected how? Through what? To what effect? The phrase is a feeling of insight with the insight removed, and the speaker is counting on you not to ask.
Psychologist Gordon Pennycook and colleagues at the University of Waterloo tested exactly this kind of sentence in a 2015 study published in Judgment and Decision Making. They fed participants random strings of buzzwords arranged into grammatical sentences, like “wholeness quiets infinite phenomena,” and found that a quarter of participants rated them profound or very profound. Participants also rated real tweets from Deepak Chopra about as profound as the random ones.
“A lot of people are just far too open to everything,” Pennycook told The Washington Post, adding that they aren’t skeptical enough of what they hear and read.
10. “Silence says more than words ever could”
It’s said out loud. By the person who has been talking for twenty minutes. Often as the capstone to a monologue about their inner life.
The phrase refutes itself the moment it leaves someone’s mouth, which is almost impressive. If silence said more, they’d have stopped.
What it actually does is close the monologue with a bow, suggesting that whatever the listener didn’t understand lives in a register too elevated for language. The listener didn’t miss anything. There wasn’t anything there.
