You’ve had dinner with this person. You asked about the new job, the move, the dog’s surgery, and got full, friendly answers to all of it. Then you drove home and realized they hadn’t asked you one thing all night.
They’d be surprised to hear it. In their mind the evening went well, and they probably like you a lot. But curiosity about other people is a habit like any other, and people who ask follow-up questions tend to be the ones everyone wants to sit beside.
The ones who rarely ask keep making the same slips, and most of them would be stunned to learn how it reads from the other chair.
1. They answer “how are you” and stop there
A coworker catches them at the coffee machine and asks how the weekend went. They give a good answer — the hike, the flat tire, the diner they found afterward. Then they stir their coffee and wait.
The coworker stands there holding a weekend nobody asked about, says “nice,” and heads back to a desk.
To the one who answered, it was a pleasant chat. To the coworker, it was a report. Do it enough mornings and people stop opening with “how was your weekend,” and the one who never returned it starts to wonder why the office seems less friendly than it used to.
2. They never circle back to last time
Three weeks ago, the neighbor mentioned a knee surgery coming up. Today they’re both at the mailboxes, the neighbor is on crutches, and what comes out is a comment about the recycling pickup.
They remember the surgery. They’re assuming that if there were news, they’d hear it.
But the follow-up is where the liking happens. People who ask more in a conversation are better liked by whoever they’re talking to, the follow-ups do most of the work, and almost nobody expects asking to matter as much as it does.
It’s what researcher Karen Huang and her team at Harvard University saw studying how questions build liking.
A follow-up proves the first conversation stuck. Skip it, and the neighbor on crutches has to decide whether to bring up the knee a second time or let it go. Most let it go, and remember who didn’t ask.
More Bolde Stories
3. They top the story instead of asking about it
Oh, I’ve been to Lisbon.
A friend has barely started in on her trip, the tiled buildings and the custard tarts and the hill that nearly finished her, and now the table is hearing about a different trip from 2016. In their head this is connecting. Same city, shared ground, what could be warmer?
It’s the hardest slip to see from inside because it comes from a good place. They’re excited. They have a thing in common and they want her to know it.
What the friend hears is that her ten days were a cue. She had a story about getting lost near the castle and never got to tell it. One line, what was the best part?, would have handed the trip back to her. She finishes her drink and lets them have Lisbon.
4. They call their silence respect for privacy
This one comes with a philosophy. If she wanted me to know, she’d tell me. I’m not going to pry.
So when a friend of twenty years goes through a divorce, they keep lunch light. They talk about a show, the traffic, the new place downtown. They believe they’re giving her room, and they’re a little proud of the restraint.
She’s sitting across from them wondering how anyone could know what her year has been and not ask about it even once. She reads it as a friend who’d rather not hear it.
Asking and prying are different acts. Prying pushes past a no. Asking leaves room for one, and most people in the worst year of their life would still rather be asked.
5. They let the other person run the interview
How does a two-hour dinner end with one person knowing everything and the other knowing nothing?
It happens on first dates all the time. One of them asks where the other grew up, how many siblings, what the job is like, whether the roommate ever paid back the deposit. The answers are funny and generous and long. Nothing of substance comes back across the table.
By dessert the date knows about the childhood dog and the half-marathon, and has been asked nothing beyond whether to split the tiramisu.
The one who talked leaves thinking it went great, since the conversation never stalled. The one who asked goes home tired, like they’d hosted a talk show, and doesn’t text back.
More Bolde Stories
6. They ask only what they’re hoping to answer
Sometimes a question does show up. “How was your weekend?” arrives before the Monday meeting, the answer gets four seconds, and then: “Nice. We ended up taking the boat out, it was unreal.”
The question was a ramp. There’s a name for it, boomerasking — asking, letting the other person answer, then swinging the topic back to yourself.
The askers think they’re making a good impression. The people on the receiving end see them as less sincere and less interested, and enjoy the exchange less than if they’d simply been told about the boat.
Researcher Alison Wood Brooks at Harvard Business School ran eight studies on the boomerask habit.
For the colleague, it’s worse than getting no question at all, because for four seconds it looked like interest.
7. They give advice before they know the situation
A nephew mentions at a cookout that he’s thinking about leaving his job. Within a minute he’s been told to never quit without another offer lined up, to max out the retirement match first, and to remember that every boss is difficult.
Nobody asked him why. Maybe the company is folding. Maybe he got into nursing school. The advice is sound and aimed at a situation that might not exist.
It also tells him what they think of his judgment, which is that he hadn’t considered the obvious. He’s been turning this over for six months. He knows about the retirement match.
The nephew nods, says “yeah, good point,” and takes the rest of it to an aunt who starts with what’s going on over there?
8. They’re the last to know and can’t work out why
The engagement is three weeks old by the time they hear about it, and they hear it from a cousin’s post. The new job, the pregnancy, the house that fell through — all of it reaches them late and secondhand.
It hurts, and they take it as being left out. Nobody tells me anything.
People share news with whoever has shown they want it. Every skipped question along the way taught family and friends that updates weren’t needed here, so the updates went elsewhere. Nobody decided to exclude them. The calls went to the ones who’d asked how the house hunt was going.
It’s one of the habits that keep friendships shallow, and the only slip here where the one who gets hurt most is the one who didn’t ask.
More Bolde Stories
Psychology says these 8 seemingly harmless habits are quietly exhausting your brain before the da...
Psychology suggests these 7 phrases reveal your confidence is quietly coming back after a hard fe...
