My mother-in-law has watched me make roughly a thousand parenting decisions she would have made differently, and she has commented on maybe four of them.
I know this because I’ve watched her face. There’s a half-second where something crosses it, the snack, the screen, the way I let my son negotiate his way out of a bath, and then it’s gone. She asks a question instead, or she hands him a towel.
She’s also the first person we call. For pickup, for sick days, for the weekend we want to get away.
Research on grandparents who help care for their grandkids suggests that kind of involvement is good for the grandparent too, and I don’t think it’s a coincidence that the grandparent who says the least is the one who gets asked the most.
Other grandparents I know can’t help themselves. They mean well. But they’ve turned every visit into a performance review, and their kids have quietly started scheduling around them.
The ones who’ve figured it out spend the afternoon talking as much as anyone. They’ve just found different things to say, and most of it comes down to the same few phrases.
1. “You know your kids better than I do.”
This is where a lot of the smart ones start. It’s true, it costs nothing, and it settles the question of who’s in charge before anyone has to argue about it.
It also happens to be accurate. A grandparent sees a grandchild on Sundays and holidays and the occasional weekday. A parent sees the 3 a.m. version, the version that won’t eat anything but crackers this month, the version that falls apart at the exact moment a stranger looks over.
Whatever a grandparent knows about children in general, the parent knows about this one in particular. Saying so out loud is simply a statement of fact, and the grandparents who make it tend to be the ones who understand that.
2. “That’s your call.”
Three words, said about the decision to skip the birthday party, or let a four-year-old watch the scary movie, or switch preschools in the middle of the year.
It works because it isn’t agreement. She’s not saying she’d do the same. She’s saying the decision belongs to someone else and she’s not going to try to pick it up.
There’s a reason this lands better than the well-meaning alternative.
A 2021 study in the Journal of Applied Psychology found that people receiving advice they didn’t ask for tended to read it as self-serving, the adviser showing off what they know, and rated it as less useful than advice they’d requested. The research was done in workplaces, but the mechanism travels. Nobody hears you should try and thinks how generous.
More Bolde Stories
Psychology says people who keep these 6 opinions to themselves at family dinners tend to be more ...
Psychology says people who grew up in the 60s and 70s without playdates, drank from the hose, and...
A letter to my boomer father who thinks working sixty hours a week and never seeing his kids was ...
3. “What are the rules at your house?”
Asked before the visit, not after the ice cream.
The grandparents who ask this get the screen limit, the bedtime, the no-snacks-in-the-car rule, and then they follow it, which is the part that matters. They may think the bedtime is early. They keep it anyway, because the bedtime belongs to someone else.
The alternative is the what happens at Grandma’s stays at Grandma’s approach, which is fun until the parent spends Monday undoing it, and eventually stops offering up Sundays.
Plenty of families have already reached that point. A national poll of parents from C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital found four in ten describe disagreements with grandparents over discipline, meals, screen time and similar choices, and roughly one in seven have limited how much time their child spends with a grandparent because of it. Parents were most likely to pull back when a grandparent refused a direct request to change.
4. “Do you want advice, or do you want me to just listen?”
When an adult child calls at 9 p.m. to say the toddler bit someone at daycare again, the reflex is to solve it. Most grandparents have a solution ready before the sentence is finished.
The ones who keep their opinions to themselves ask first. Sometimes the answer is advice, please, I’m out of ideas. Just as often it’s I just needed to say it to someone. Either way, the parent chose, and choosing changes how the next ten minutes feel.
Clinical psychologist James Kirby, who helped evaluate a group program for grandparents providing regular childcare, has written that the number one thing parents dislike from grandparents is unsolicited parenting advice. One of the phrases the program teaches grandparents to use is almost exactly this one: “Can I help at all, or would you like me to just listen?”
5. “A lot has changed since I did this.”
This is the phrase that replaces we did it that way and you turned out fine.
Beyond being nicer, it has the advantage of being true. Crib bumpers, stomach sleeping, solids at two months, forward-facing car seats for toddlers: a lot of what was standard thirty years ago is now on the list of things pediatricians ask you not to do.
Nobody who says this is apologizing for how they raised their own kids. They’re acknowledging that the manual got rewritten and they haven’t read the new edition, which is a reasonable thing for them to admit.
The gap is real. In a 2017 survey of grandparents raising their grandchildren, presented at a pediatrics conference, Dr. Andrew Adesman found that many held outdated health beliefs, including 44 percent who thought an ice bath was a good way to bring down a high fever. “We shouldn’t assume that just because they’ve raised a child before, they’re experts,” he told CNN.
More Bolde Stories
6. “I’m here if you ever want my two cents.”
Said once. Then never repeated.
The offer sits on the table and the parent knows where it is. The grandparent doesn’t slide it closer every visit or ask whether they’ve thought about it yet. If the parent wants it, they’ll pick it up. If they don’t, the offer has cost nobody anything.
Most grandparents assume they have two options: speak up or stay silent. There’s a third, and this is it. You make it clear you have something to say, then you trust the other person to ask for it, which most of them eventually do, precisely because they weren’t pushed.
7. “You’re doing a good job.”
Said plainly, with a period at the end. The version with a but attached doesn’t count.
New parents get corrected by everyone. The pediatrician, the internet, the woman in line at the pharmacy, the other parents at the playground with their own strong feelings about sunscreen. Almost nobody tells them they’re doing fine.
Coming from the person who raised you, it hits differently. It’s the one review they actually wanted, and the grandparents who keep their criticism to themselves seem to understand that praise is the thing they’re uniquely positioned to give.
8. “I’ll follow your lead.”
This one comes out in the moment rather than on the phone. The restaurant, the checkout line, the meltdown in the parking lot. The kid is losing it, two adults are standing there, and both of them have an instinct.
The grandparent who says this steps back half a pace and looks at the parent. Whatever the parent does, she backs. If the parent walks the child to the car, she carries the bags. If the parent crouches down and waits it out, she waits too.
Two adults handling a child two different ways in the same sixty seconds is confusing for everyone, and the child will notice the disagreement before either adult admits it exists. One approach, even an imperfect one, beats a contested one.
More Bolde Stories
9. “Tell me more about that.”
The parent mentions gentle parenting. Or baby-led weaning, or the Montessori thing, or the fact that they’ve decided not to do time-outs.
The grandparent could say in my day. Everyone in the room knows that sentence is often locked and loaded. Instead she asks what it means, and how it’s going, and what made them try it. She might still think it’s ridiculous. She’s decided that finding out is more interesting than being right about it.
Psychologist Jeff Segal, who works with grandparents who’ve become estranged from their adult children, has written that the comments he hears most in his practice sound like back in my day, we didn’t hold babies so much, and that the families who stay close are the ones who choose curiosity over criticism when parenting styles differ.
The quiet grandparents still have plenty of opinions
Some of those opinions are probably right. They’ve just ran the numbers on what an opinion costs and what it buys, and decided the trade rarely works in their favor.
The cost has a number attached. In the first large national survey on family estrangement, Cornell’s Karl Pillemer found that 27 percent of American adults had cut off contact with a family member, with about 10 percent estranged from a parent or child. That figure includes extended family, and it covers many kinds of rifts, but grandparents who lose access to their grandchildren rarely lose it over one comment. They lose it over the accumulation.
None of these phrases are tricks. They’re what it sounds like when someone has decided that being in the room matters more than being right in it. And the reward, as my mother-in-law could tell you, is that the phone keeps ringing.
