I’m in a marriage that feels like a quiet hostage situation, and I’ve realized that I’m not staying for the love; I’m staying because I’m terrified of the version of myself I’ll have to become to burn my entire life to the ground.

I’m in a marriage that feels like a quiet hostage situation, and I’ve realized that I’m not staying for the love; I’m staying because I’m terrified of the version of myself I’ll have to become to burn my entire life to the ground.

Nobody forced me to stay.

That’s the part I have to keep reminding myself, because the hostage metaphor only goes so far.

There is no captor. There is no threat.

There is just a life I built with another person, over many years, that has somehow become a structure I can’t see my way out of—not because the doors are locked, but because walking through them would require burning down everything on the other side.

The marriage is not violent. It is not cruel in any way I could point to in court. It is something harder to explain than that.

It is quiet. It is a little gray. It is the specific loneliness of being in a room with someone who knows you well and sees you less and less.

It is going to bed next to a person and lying there in the dark with a feeling that has no clean name—not hatred, not even sadness exactly, more like the awareness of an absence where something used to be.

I have been lying next to that absence for long enough that I’ve started to think of it as the furniture. Just part of the room. Just how things are.

I know that’s not okay. I know it while I’m writing it. I knew it before I started writing it. But knowing it has not, so far, changed anything.

What I mean by hostage

A very unhappy married couple in bed.
Shutterstock

I mean that I have negotiated myself down to a version of this life I can survive.

Not thrive in. Survive. I have learned which topics to avoid, which moods to read, and which version of myself to bring to which situation. I have gotten very good at managing an atmosphere. I have, without ever deciding to, become someone whose primary domestic skill is keeping the temperature of the room from tipping into something worse.

That’s the hostage part. Not that he’s done anything to make me feel that way—or not only that. But that I have adapted so thoroughly to the conditions of this particular life that I have arranged myself around it rather than inside it. That I am always slightly braced. Always monitoring. Always one small degree away from full presence because full presence, in this life, doesn’t feel entirely safe.

I don’t think he knows this. I’m not sure I fully knew it until I said it out loud to a friend six months ago and watched her face go very still.

I know what I’m staying for, and it isn’t him

People stay in marriages for a lot of reasons that aren’t love. Comfort. Children. Money. Fear. Inertia. The specific exhaustion of having already invested so much that the idea of stopping feels like a loss too large to compute.

I’m familiar with most of those.

But the one I keep coming back to is simpler and harder to say. I am staying because leaving would require me to become someone I’m not sure I have in me. Not the paperwork, not the logistics, not even the grief. The becoming.

Leaving this life means becoming the person who left it. Who burned the house down. Who decided that what she needed mattered more than what she’d built. Who looked at fifteen years of shared history and said: This isn’t enough, and I’m going anyway.

I don’t know if I’m that person.

I’m not sure I want to be that person, even though I know she might be freer than I am. There is something about the scorched-earth version of this—the packing, the telling, the watching of a shared life come apart—that feels like a violence I’m not sure I’m capable of committing, even against a situation that is slowly committing one against me.

What I’m actually afraid of

Not being alone. I’ve been alone before, and I know I can do it.

Not starting over. Hard, but survivable.

What I’m afraid of is the in-between. The moment after the match is struck and before anything new exists. The period of pure rubble, where I am just a person who blew up her life and has to figure out what comes next from inside the ruins.

I’m afraid of who I’ll be in that period. Not in a romantic sense—I’m not worried about being unlovable or undesirable or any of the things women are told to be afraid of when a marriage ends. I’m worried about the version of me that will have to hold this alone. That will have to sit inside the weight of having decided this and live there while everything settles.

She sounds exhausting. She sounds like she’ll need a lot of things I don’t currently know how to give her.

And I don’t have a safety net for her either. I know what that version of life costs, in money and energy and the particular toll of rebuilding from scratch, and the cost is real and it is high and I’m not sure I have the reserves for it right now.

So I stay. And I lie next to the absence. And I tell myself I’m being practical.

What nobody tells you about the quiet ones

The loud marriages are easier to leave. There’s evidence. There’s a clear story. There’s a reason you can give people that they’ll nod at and understand.

The quiet ones are harder. Because nothing is wrong, exactly. Because he is not a bad man. Because the marriage has the shape of a marriage—shared history, shared property, shared habits—even if it has lost some of the substance.

And because the question you have to answer, if you’re honest, is not “is this a bad situation?” but “is this enough?”

That question is harder to answer. And the answer, even when you know it, is harder to act on. Because not enough isn’t the same as unlivable. Because you can survive not enough for a very long time before it becomes a reason.

I’ve been surviving it for a while now.

And the strange thing about surviving something is that it starts to feel like a choice, even when it isn’t. Like staying is something you’re actively deciding rather than something that’s just happening to you by default. That confusion is part of what makes the quiet ones so hard to leave. You can’t always tell where the fear ends, and the decision begins.

Where I actually am now

I’m not leaving. Not right now. Not because I’ve decided to stay forever—I don’t know that—but because I haven’t yet become the person who can do what leaving requires.

Maybe I will. Maybe the accumulation will reach a point where the fear of staying outweighs the fear of going, and the person I need to be will simply arrive out of necessity, the way people sometimes do.

Or maybe I’ll keep lying next to the absence and negotiating myself down and surviving, until surviving stops being enough.

I don’t know which one it will be. I know both are possible. I know I’m not done figuring it out.

What I know for certain is that I’m not staying for the love.

I haven’t been for a while.

And saying that—plainly, without dressing it up—is the most honest thing I’ve done in this marriage in a long time.

Editor’s Note: This piece is part of our “As Told to Bolde” series where we share personal stories from individuals we have interviewed or surveyed. For more information on how we create content, please review our Editorial Policy.

Halle Kaye has been writing for Bolde since 2014. She writes primarily about dating, marriage, divorce, parenting, friendship and family dynamics.

As someone who is unapologetically hyper-independent, Halle writes extensively about people who are high-functioning, high-achieving and tend to rely exclusively on themselves. She writes about the origins of this psychological profile as well as the loneliness that often comes with it. She regularly shares her personal experiences navigating parenting, family and friendship with these tendencies and speaks candidly about those moments she wishes she had someone she could rely on.

Halle is also the author of the popular 2012 dating book Maybe He's Just an Ahole: Ditch Denial, Embrace Your Worth, and Find True Love! which was based on her dating experiences in college. Halle splits her time between Westport, CT and New York.