Subtle Signs a New Friend Might Have a Hidden Agenda

Subtle Signs a New Friend Might Have a Hidden Agenda

Making new friends can be exciting, but not everyone comes into your life with the best intentions. Sometimes, people hide ulterior motives behind a friendly smile and easy conversation. While most friendships are genuine, others can leave you feeling uneasy without knowing why. If you’ve started questioning a new connection, here are 15 subtle signs that they might have a hidden agenda.

1. They’re Too Invested in Your Success

At first, their enthusiasm for your achievements seems supportive, but then it feels… off. Instead of celebrating your success, they might turn it into an opportunity to subtly undermine you or question your worth. Maybe they focus on how your win affects them rather than being genuinely happy for you. Real friends cheer for you without strings attached; someone with a hidden agenda sees your success as a threat or a tool for their own gain.

2. They Keep You on Edge with “Jokes”

friends hanging out on the beach

If their humor consistently has a sharp edge, it’s worth paying attention. They might disguise cutting remarks as “just kidding” but leave you feeling unsettled or self-conscious. These digs might seem harmless at first, but over time, they chip away at your confidence. Genuine friends don’t use humor to put you down—they lift you up and make you feel comfortable, not self-doubtful.

3. They Always Have a Subtle Critique

Do they always have a critique ready, even when it’s not asked for? While constructive feedback is great, this person’s constant nitpicking might feel more like an effort to undermine your confidence. Whether it’s about your appearance, work, or decisions, their comments are rarely encouraging. Real friends offer support and constructive advice, but someone with a hidden agenda uses critiques to keep you second-guessing yourself.

4. Compliments Are Conspicuously Absent

Think back—have they ever truly celebrated your wins or complimented your efforts? If their support is missing when it matters most, it could be a sign they’re not rooting for you. Hidden agendas often manifest in a refusal to acknowledge your strengths or achievements. Their silence isn’t just forgetfulness; it’s deliberate. Genuine friends recognize and appreciate your efforts, no matter how small.

5. They Tell You Only What You Want to Hear

Two female friends sitting at cafe having coffee and gossiping. Female friends meeting in a coffee shop on a weekend.

This might feel flattering at first—they’re always agreeing with you or showering you with praise. But over time, you might notice it’s all surface-level. They don’t challenge you or offer real advice because their goal isn’t your growth—it’s to keep you complacent. Real friends know when to tell hard truths because they want what’s best for you. Someone with a hidden agenda keeps things shallow to stay in your good graces without putting in the effort to truly care.

6. Your Happiness Seems to Irritate Them

If your good news seems to bother them, that’s a big red flag. Instead of sharing in your joy, they might downplay your happiness or make passive-aggressive remarks. Their discomfort with your success often stems from jealousy or their own insecurities. A true friend celebrates your wins and wants to see you happy. Someone with a hidden agenda will try to dim your light so they can shine brighter.

7. They Make Everything a Competition

friends chatting over coffee

Do they always need to one-up you? Whether it’s their career, social life, or even the smallest of achievements, this friend seems obsessed with being “better.” Healthy friendships thrive on mutual respect, not constant comparison. When someone makes every interaction feel like a contest, it’s a sign they’re more focused on their own ego than building a genuine connection with you.

8. They Almost Seem To Thrive on Your Struggles

If they only seem to show up when things are going wrong, take note. While it’s great to have someone there during tough times, this person might secretly enjoy seeing you struggle. They’ll offer “help” or sympathy, but their support vanishes as soon as you’re back on your feet. A real friend sticks around through both the highs and the lows, not just when you’re vulnerable.

9. They Shoot Down Your Ideas

Whenever you share an idea or dream, they’re quick to find flaws or reasons why it won’t work. It’s not constructive criticism—it’s dismissive and discouraging. This behavior often comes from a place of insecurity; by making you doubt yourself, they maintain a sense of control. Real friends might offer advice or a reality check, but they do so with encouragement, not negativity. Someone with a hidden agenda, however, thrives on making you question your potential.

10. Conversations Feel Shallow

If every interaction feels surface-level, it might not be a coincidence. They avoid meaningful conversations and keep things light to avoid showing vulnerability or building a deeper connection. This distance often hints at their unwillingness to invest in the friendship genuinely. Real friends dive into the tough stuff and share openly, while someone with a hidden agenda keeps their guard up, focusing on what they can get out of the relationship instead.

11. Their Non-Verbal Cues Don’t Match Their Words

Body language speaks volumes. Do they seem disinterested or annoyed when you talk about your achievements? Maybe they avoid eye contact or cross their arms during conversations. These subtle cues often reveal more than their words. A genuine friend’s body language aligns with their support—they’re engaged and attentive. Someone with a hidden agenda might say all the right things but betray their true feelings through closed-off or dismissive gestures.

12. They Gossip About You

Finding out they’ve been talking about you behind your back is a clear red flag. Whether it’s spreading rumors or sharing your personal information, this behavior shows a complete lack of respect. They might justify it as harmless chatter, but real friends don’t betray your trust like that. Gossip is often a tactic to manipulate or control the narrative about you, and it’s a surefire sign that their intentions aren’t pure.

13. They Downplay Your Achievements

two friends having serious conversation

You share exciting news, and instead of celebrating with you, they brush it off or change the subject. Their comments might seem casual, but they’re designed to make your accomplishments feel less significant. This behavior often stems from jealousy or a need to diminish your success to elevate themselves. A true friend would be your biggest cheerleader, while someone with a hidden agenda can’t stand seeing you shine brighter than them.

14. They Flake on You When It Matters

If they’re constantly canceling plans or ghosting you when you need support, it’s a sign they don’t value your time or friendship. While life happens and things come up, someone who consistently flakes when it’s inconvenient for them isn’t prioritizing you. A hidden agenda often means they’re only around when it benefits them, and when it doesn’t? You’re left feeling like an afterthought.

15. They Use Criticism as “Concern”

When they criticize your choices, it’s often disguised as “caring advice.” They’ll say things like, “I’m just worried about you,” but their tone feels more condescending than supportive. This backhanded concern is a way to make you second-guess yourself while maintaining the facade of a good friend. Real friends offer constructive feedback without tearing you down, while someone with a hidden agenda uses “concern” as a weapon to keep you doubting your decisions.

This content was created by a real person with the assistance of AI.

 

Sinitta Weston grew up in Edinburgh but moved to Sydney, Australia to for college and never came back. She works as a chemical engineer during the day and at night, she writes articles about love and relationships. She's her friends' go-to for dating advice (though she struggles to take the same advice herself). Her INFJ personality makes her extra sensitive to others' feelings and this allows her to help people through tough times with ease. Hopefully, her articles can do that for you.