I wake up most nights somewhere between 2 and 4 a.m. Not groggy enough to roll over and disappear again. Awake awake. Ceiling-staring, pillow-flipping, brain-already-running awake. The kind of awake where you know you’re not going back anytime soon.
For years I blamed anxiety. Then caffeine. Then the fact that I’ve never been a great sleeper.
Then I found out that historians had been going through centuries of old diaries, letters, and court records, finding references to what one researcher called an ancient pattern.
Going to bed, waking in the middle of the night, and going back down for what they called a second sleep.
Suddenly my 3 a.m. ceiling-staring felt a little more ordinary than I’d thought.
Historians found thousands of references to a first sleep and a second sleep
Roger Ekirch, a historian at Virginia Tech, has spent decades collecting references to this pattern.
In diaries, letters, legal depositions, novels, prayer books, and medical texts from preindustrial Europe and beyond, people kept mentioning two distinct periods of sleep with a wakeful stretch in between.
Walter A. Brown, a psychiatrist at Brown University, wrote about the pattern Ekirch assembled and described it:
People went to bed within an hour or so of sunset, slept for about four hours, woke up, stayed awake for a couple of hours, and then returned to sleep until morning.
The wakeful period wasn’t treated like an emergency. People prayed. They talked. They had sex. They checked on the house, visited a neighbor, thought about their dreams, or just lay there in the dark doing nothing. It was part of the night.
The sixteenth-century French physician Laurent Joubert wrote that laborers did their best conceiving after the first sleep. English courts recorded witnesses mentioning their first sleep the way you’d mention breakfast: as an ordinary feature of the night that everyone understood.
Ekirch has now found more than two thousand references in a dozen languages going as far back as ancient Greece. That doesn’t prove everyone slept this way.
A more recent historical look at the same records argues the texts show a wider mix of patterns, not one universal two-sleep system.
But the broader point holds: the idea that humans have always slept in a single unbroken stretch is a modern invention, not a biological law.
Eight uninterrupted hours may be a cultural expectation that arrived with gas lamps and factory shifts, not the biological default we treat it as.
A sleep researcher accidentally recreated the pattern in a lab
In the early 1990s, a psychiatrist named Thomas Wehr at the National Institute of Mental Health ran an experiment. He put a small group of people in darkness for 14 hours a night, roughly the length of a winter night before electric light.
He let them sleep as much as they wanted.
For the first few days they slept a lot, about eleven hours, as if paying off a debt. Then the rhythm changed. Their sleep stopped looking anything like what modern people would call normal.
It took a few weeks, but their sleep rearranged itself. They stopped sleeping in one block. Instead they fell asleep, woke after about four hours, stayed calmly awake for an hour or two, and then slept again for another four hours.
Wehr described the wakeful period as calm and meditative. It wasn’t restless or anxious. It was a calmer, different kind of being awake than most of us experience at 3 a.m.
That doesn’t mean your 3 a.m. wake-up is an ancient program switching back on. But it does show a point simpler and more useful: the human sleep system is flexible enough to organize itself into two periods under the right conditions.
A middle-of-the-night awakening may be far more ordinary than a culture built around eight uninterrupted hours makes it seem.
More Bolde Stories
The bigger change may be that modern life taught us to treat waking up as failure
Ekirch’s argument is that consolidated sleep became the cultural expectation as artificial lighting spread and industrial schedules tightened in the 1800s.
Bedtime moved later. Nighttime activity expanded. The gap between sleeps got squeezed until it disappeared entirely.
The expectation became: go to bed once, wake up once, done. Anything else was a problem to solve, a symptom to treat, a sign you were doing sleep wrong.
That changes the experience of opening your eyes at 3 a.m.
If you believe waking up is abnormal, the minute your eyes open you start doing math. I only have four hours left. Why am I awake? Tomorrow is ruined.
The heart rate ticks up. The jaw tightens. You start trying to force yourself back to sleep, which is one of the least effective ways to fall asleep.
That anxiety can become its own problem. The waking itself may have lasted ten minutes. The panic about the waking keeps you up for an hour.
Sometimes the worst part of a nighttime awakening isn’t the awakening itself. It’s the story you tell yourself about what it means.
A person in 1650 who woke at midnight might have said a prayer and gone back to sleep.
A person in 2026 who wakes at 3 a.m. reaches for their phone, sees the time, and spends the next forty minutes calculating how tired they’re going to be.
But not every 3 a.m. wake-up deserves a historical explanation
There’s no good evidence that segmented sleep is healthier than consolidated sleep. Different people may do better with different patterns, and modern schedules are built around getting most of your rest in one nighttime stretch.
If you wake briefly, feel calm, fall back asleep without much trouble, and function well the next day, that’s a very different situation from waking for hours every night and feeling wrecked by morning.
The first one doesn’t need fixing. The second one might. The distinction matters, and only you and your body know which one you’re living.
A large European survey of more than 22,000 adults found that nearly a third reported waking at least three nights a week. For most of them, the waking itself wasn’t the problem.
A much smaller group had serious difficulty getting back to sleep, and that difficulty was strongly tied to pain, psychiatric conditions, and daytime impairment.
Middle-of-the-night waking can also be part of insomnia, sleep apnea, restless legs, menopause, medication side effects, alcohol, or plain old stress.
If you’re awake for long stretches regularly, exhausted during the day, snoring, gasping, or noticing your sleep getting worse over time, humans used to sleep in shifts is not a reason to ignore it.
The useful takeaway is narrower than the headline might suggest. Waking once at 3 a.m. does not automatically mean your sleep is broken.
People once had a whole name for the sleep that came after
You’re awake, it’s dark, and your mind has decided that right now is the time to replay a conversation from 2014.
Maybe sometimes it is anxiety. Maybe sometimes you had too much wine, or the room is too warm, or your body just does this. Not every explanation needs to be historical.
But there’s a comfort in knowing that people have been waking in the middle of the night for a very long time, and for most of that history, nobody panicked about it.
They had a name for the sleep that came after. They expected the gap. They used it, or they didn’t, and then they went back to sleep. The night had a middle, and the middle belonged to them.
You don’t have to greet every awakening with Oh no, here we go again. Sometimes you’re just awake for a little while. It may not be the crisis your brain insists it is.
More Bolde Stories
The art of disappointing people on purpose: 8 times letting someone down is the most honest thing...
You don’t have to ‘reinvent’ yourself to be happy in your 60s and 70s. There’s a better approach ...
