My friend’s husband is one of the easiest people I know to talk to.
He’s funny. He remembers your kids’ names and asks how the new job is going. He will stand at a grill for two hours and keep six conversations alive at once.
A few summers ago I realized I had known him for over a decade and could not name one thing he was worried about. Not one.
That’s what a guarded man usually looks like. We picture someone cold and silent with his arms crossed.
More often he’s the friendliest guy at the party, and the friendliness is doing a job. It keeps everything moving quickly enough that the conversation never lands on him. It’s part of why an emotionally unavailable man can take years to recognize. Nothing he says ever sounds like a wall.
He has plenty of company.
In a recent poll asking Americans about their friendships in 2021, 48 percent of women said they had shared their personal feelings with a friend in the past week. For men, it was 30 percent. Younger men were no more likely to have done it than older ones.
None of the phrases below prove anything on their own. Every man says them, and most of the time they mean exactly what they sound like. The tell is range.
A man who’s doing fine will sometimes tell you he’s fried, or annoyed, or that this month has been a lot. A guarded one rotates through the same handful of answers for years, and you never hear anything else.
1. “Can’t complain”
Often followed by wouldn’t do any good if I did, and a laugh.
Listen to what the phrase says. Not that there’s nothing to complain about. That he can’t. It’s a small joke about a rule, and the rule is real. Somewhere along the way he learned that a man who lists his troubles is a man people get tired of.
So he answers the question without answering it. You asked how he is, and he told you his policy on discussing it.
It’s a perfectly pleasant thing to say. It’s also something a person can say for thirty years without ever updating it.
2. “I’m just tired”
The excuse nobody can argue with. There’s no follow-up question for tired. You can’t be tired wrong.
That’s what makes it useful. He was quiet at dinner, short with the kids, somewhere else all weekend, and tired covers all of it without opening a single door.
Sometimes he even believes it.
Mayo Clinic’s guidance on depression in men points out that for many men, sadness isn’t the main symptom. Tiredness, irritability and headaches can show up in its place, along with a habit of seeking distraction so he doesn’t have to deal with feelings at all.
Most tired men are just tired. But if it has been the answer since roughly March, it stopped being about sleep a while ago.
More Bolde Stories
3. “It is what it is”
Five words that end a topic. His dad’s diagnosis. The layoff. The friend he doesn’t talk to anymore.
It sounds like acceptance, and sometimes it is. But real acceptance tends to come after some talking. He says what it cost him, and then he makes peace with it. This version skips the first part. It arrives about four seconds after the subject comes up, which is too fast for anyone to have accepted anything.
What the phrase really does is reclassify a feeling as a fact. Facts don’t need discussing.
Watch what he says next. If it’s a change of subject, that was a door closing.
4. “I don’t know, I haven’t really thought about it”
Said about the thing he has obviously been thinking about. Whether he’s happy at work. How it felt when his brother didn’t call.
This one is tricky, because it isn’t always a dodge.
University of Akron psychologist Ronald Levant has spent decades on what he calls normative male alexithymia. His argument is that boys who are discouraged from expressing vulnerable feelings never develop a vocabulary for them, or much awareness of them, and grow into men who struggle to put emotion into words. He is careful to call it mild to moderate, nothing like the clinical condition, and to say some men rather than all of them.
So I don’t know might be the most honest sentence he says all day. He’s not refusing to tell you. He opened the drawer and nothing in it was labeled.
The guarded part is the second half. I haven’t really thought about it means he’s not planning to start.
5. “Living the dream”
Delivered deadpan, at the coffee machine or in the school pickup line. Everybody laughs. Conversation over.
Sarcasm is the most socially rewarded form of guardedness there is. The joke technically admits something is off, since nobody says it when they are in fact living the dream. But it admits it in a format that can’t be followed up. Ask wait, are you okay? and you’re the one who didn’t get the joke.
Funny men get a lot of credit for openness they haven’t actually shown.
He’ll tell a brutal story about himself, and it feels like closeness. Notice that the story is polished. It has a punchline. He’s told it forty times.
That’s the stuff that stopped hurting years ago. Whatever still hurts doesn’t have a punchline yet, so you don’t hear about it.
More Bolde Stories
6. “Anyway, enough about me”
Said roughly forty seconds into talking about himself. Then he asks you a really good question, and he listens to the answer, which is why nobody notices.
Everyone describes him as a great listener. He knows about your mother’s surgery and your nightmare boss. Years in, the ledger is wildly lopsided and he seems completely fine with that.
Psychologists James Gross of Stanford and Oliver John of Berkeley ran five studies on people who habitually hide what they feel, and found they do worse in their relationships, not better. Men scored higher on suppression than women in every sample. Habitual suppressors shared less of everything, the good feelings as well as the bad ones. Their friends could tell they were holding back. They didn’t dislike them for it. They just didn’t feel close to them.
The participants were college students, so it’s fair to ask how neatly that maps onto a man of fifty, but anyone who knows this guy will recognize the outline.
That’s the cost, and it’s a quiet one. Nobody is mad at him. Everybody likes him. Nobody knows him.
7. “I’ll figure it out”
The job. The money. Whatever is going on in his marriage. You offer help, or just an ear, and he thanks you like he means it and says he’ll figure it out.
He usually does. That’s the problem. It keeps working just well enough that he never has to learn the other way.
It isn’t really about competence.
In his mind, telling you would be handing you a problem, and he is someone who handles problems. He doesn’t distribute them.
In that same Survey Center poll, 41 percent of women had received emotional support from a friend in the past week. For men it was 21 percent. And 85 percent of married men said their wife is the first person they go to with a personal problem, which for a lot of them means she’s the only one.
He gets half the support, and not because his friends wouldn’t give it. He would have to say the sentence first.
Most guarded men aren’t hiding anything dramatic
Sometimes quiet is just quiet.
In a Reddit thread where men were asked what they never say out loud, one explained that when he goes silent mid-conversation he isn’t upset. He’s thinking about something unrelated, possibly a movie from 2003. Believe him.
But another man in that thread wrote that men would like to be more vulnerable, except that “you seem to like us less when we show that side.”
That’s the part worth holding onto. For most guarded men there’s no secret behind the wall. There’s a prediction. He expects the real answer to cost him something, and at some point in his life he was probably right.
NYU developmental psychologist Niobe Way has spent more than thirty years interviewing boys, and she describes the same arc again and again. At thirteen they talk about their best friends with open love. By fifteen or sixteen they’ve gone quiet and they miss it. She told NPR that “men are starving for this conversation,” and that the holdup is simply that nobody wants to go first.
So don’t pry. Prying confirms everything he already suspects about what happens when he opens up. Go first with something small and true of your own, ideally in the car or over a task, where nobody has to look at anybody.
Then, the next time he says can’t complain, wait a beat longer than is comfortable. Sometimes there’s a second sentence behind the first one. It may have been waiting a long time.
